Literary Yard

Search for meaning

Queen Padmini of Mewar: History, Myth and the Indigenous Tradition of Historiography

By: Dr. Tamali Neogi

The English rendition of Dr. Madhav Hada’s Padmini: Ithihas aur Katha-Kavyaki Jugalbandi, titled Queen Padmini of Mewar: Ithihas aur Deshaj Aakhyan, appeared in 2026. Over the years, historical fiction—such as Anuja Chandramouli’s Rani Padmavati: The Burning Queen, Mridula Behari’s Padmini: The Spirited Queen of Chittor, and Sutapa Basu’s first-person narrative Padmavati: The Queen Tells Her Own Story—has explored the Queen’s emotional strength, resolve, and journey from Singhaldeep to Jauhar. Simultaneously, rigorous scholarship has interrogated the historicity of the Padmini-Ratansen episode. Works like Ramya Sreenivasan’s The Many Lives of a Rajput Queen, B. K. Kakra’s Rani Padmini: The Heroine of Chittor, and Dr. Chandramani Singh and Surendra Bothra’s Historicity of Padmini examine oral traditions, monastic records, and epigraphic evidence to distinguish historical events from poetic embellishments and identify indigenous sources predating Malik Muhammad Jayasi’s Padmavat.

Dr. Hada’s book, translated by Professor Pradeep Trikha, represents a culmination of this scholarly engagement. Beyond challenging modern historians who reject the episode’s historicity, the work deconstructs the rigid conceptual boundary between history and legend. By examining regional bardic traditions, poetic accounts, and Mewar’s internal cultural records, it synthesizes scattered findings into a coherent framework that demonstrates how oral traditions preserve authentic historical memory.

In his Foreword, Professor Harish Trivedi illuminates what likely drew Professor Trikha to translate this text for an international readership: questions surrounding Padmini’s existence “interrogate not merely the existence of Padmini. They also call into question the larger issue of the correlation between Literature and History, and equally, the understanding of these two concepts in India and the West” (Foreword v). By interrogating European historiographical conventions to retrieve Indian historical traditions, Hada’s work engages deeply with cultural and civilizational consciousness.

While the book’s cover evokes a remote landscape of myth, the Introduction anchors readers in indigenous historical ground. As Professor Trikha states, his objective is to “[c]ritically examine how indigenous sources portray Mewar’s cultural vibrancy during this period while questioning the historicity of the legend, its allegorical layers, and its implications for gender, nationalism, and cultural identity” (Introduction x). Organized into five thematic sections—Indian historiographical traditions; indigenous narratives interweaving history and folklore; historical sources; history and myth; and ideologies, faiths, and beliefs—the book systematically proves that the omission of the episode from a single account, such as Amir Khusrau’s writings, cannot be treated as conclusive proof of its ahistorical nature.

The opening chapter, “Indian Tradition of Historiography,” challenges the Eurocentric assumption that India lacked historical consciousness. Hada argues that medieval political upheavals, rather than philosophical apathy, obscured India’s historical records, and highlights how Indian storytelling transformed historical experiences into narrative poetry (katha-kavya). Tracing the relationship between Itihasa and the Puranas, Hada notes that vernacular and Sanskrit biographical narratives “blend history and literature, incorporating rich literary traditions” (p. 23). Invoking Rabindranath Tagore’s critique of evaluating different nations’ histories through an identical framework, Hada cautions modern Indian scholars against dismissing indigenous memory-keeping as absurd simply because Indian intellectual traditions never strictly separated literature from history.

In the second chapter, Hada examines compositions by Jain sages and poets—including Hemratan, Labhyodaya, and Dalpat Vijay—alongside works like Gora Badal Kavit, Gora-Badal Padmini Chaupai, Gora Badal Katha, and Padmini Charitra Chaupai. Through close analysis of composition dates and narrative patterns, Hada and Trikha refute the claim that all indigenous narratives derived from Jayasi’s Padmavat, showing instead how Padmavat itself drew upon pre-existing local traditions while adding Sufi allegory. Genealogical records such as Padminisamiyo, Khummanraso, Ranaraso, and Chittaur-Udaipur Patnama further illustrate how folk traditions embed historical lineage within creative expression.

The third chapter, “Historical Sources,” critiques modern historians’ reluctance to accept Rajasthan’s public libraries and oral folk archives as valid evidence. Hada demonstrates how historical narratives evolve imaginatively across generations of transmission without losing their historical core—a dynamic explored further in the fourth chapter, “History and Myth.” Challenging the popular conflation of “myth” with fabrication, Hada examines the term’s etymology, validity, and intentionality. He accounts for the silence of Islamic chroniclers, contests Jayasi’s status as the narrative’s originator, and evaluates the historicity of Padmini, Ratansen, Gora-Badal, Raghav Chetan, and the Jauhar. Ultimately, Hada shows that while European frameworks dismiss the episode as fiction, Indian historical consciousness understands it as a mythic reality rooted in lived historical experience.

The final chapter, “Ideology, Faith and Belief,” foregrounds what the Padmini-Ratansen narrative reveals about medieval Indian political structures, Rajput origins, and social values.

Overall, Dr. Madhav Hada’s study offers a vital reorientation of Indian historiography and the interplay between myth, poetry, and history. Bringing such nuanced scholarship across linguistic boundaries demands exceptional academic discernment, and Professor Trikha’s translation succeeds seamlessly. Preserving the analytical precision and argumentative momentum of the Hindi original, Trikha’s English rendering reads effortlessly, making a landmark work of indigenous historiography accessible to a global audience.

###

Dr. Tamali Neogi who is an Associate Professor of English Literature at Guskara Mahavidyalaya, affiliated with the University of Burdwan in West Bengal 

Leave a Reply

Related Posts