Literary Yard

Search for meaning

By James Aitchison

Are rejections — dozens, even hundreds — something every writer experiences?  And what does rejection teach writers?  Isaac Asimov has the answer: “You must keep sending work out.  If you have talent you will achieve a measure of success, but only if you persist.”

The publishing industry is full of stupid mistakes.  Believe it or not, J. K. Rowling’s Harry Potterwas rejected 12 times.  Imagine if she hadn’t sent it out a thirteenth time!  

And we can only pity the editors who passed on her manuscript.

It is the rare author’s journey that isn’t filled with rejections.  Even the ubiquitous best-selling James Patterson, formerly a creative director at a New York ad agency, tasted rejection 23 times.  Patterson said, “I keep a list of all the editors who turned [my manuscript] down.  Sometimes they send me books and ask for blurbs.  Mostly, though, they’re dead”.

Two lawyers dreamed of becomning authors while practising law.  They wrote at night and early mornings, sending out their manuscripts again and again.

John Grisham submitted A Time to Kill to 28 publishers before achieving success; he went on to sell 400 million books.  Another lawyer, David Baldacci, suffered rejection until Absolute Power soared onto the best-seller list.  Still at the top of his game, Baldacci argues that an author must have “an incredible motor”.

….

Talent and resilience are prerequisites for aspiring authors.  Most give up after a handful of rejections.  As Neil Gaiman once noted, “You’ll either shrug and keep going.  Or you stop and get a real job”.

Some rejections are terse and impersonal.  Others are decidedly insulting.  The best-selling author Mary Higgins Clark faced 40 rejections.  She was told, “Your story is light, slight, and trite”.

It defies belief that Rudyard Kipling was once told, “I’m sorry, Mr. Kipling, but you just don’t know how to use the English language”.

And it’s equally incredible that Theodor Seuss Geisel’s first Dr. Seuss book was rejected by 27 different publishers.  Why?  It was “too different from other juveniles on the market to warrant its selling”.

Pierre Boulle was told his Bridge Over the River Kwai was “a very bad book”.

Richard Bach’s Jonathan Livingston Seagull was rejected because “it will never make it as a paperback”.  The book sold more than 7.25 million copies.

An editor rejecting The War of the Worlds told H. G. Wells that his book was, “An endless nightmare.  I don’t believe it would take”.

Herman Melville’s Moby Dick was slammed as being “very long, rather old-fashioned”.

Ursula K. LeGuin was told The Left Hand of Darkness was “unreadable”.  It subsequently won both a Nebula and a Hugo Award and rehspaed a genre.

In 1949, Jorge Luis Borges was deemed “utterly untranslatable”.

Emily Dickinson’s poems were rejected posthumously because they were “queer — the rhymes are all wrong”.  Edgar Allan Poe, pleading poverty, read his poem The Raven to the assembled staff members of a magazine.  He was sent on his way with fifteen dollars towards paying his debts.

“Good God, I can’t publish this!” an editor told William Faulkner when rejecting Sanctuary.

Perhaps the most inspiring rejection tale concerns Joseph Heller’s Catch-22.  Originally titled Catch-18, it was rejected by 21 publishers.  When at last it was accepted, Heller’s publisher requested the title be changed; Leon Uris, a well-established author, was launching his newest book Mila 18 at the same time as Heller’s book and the publisher feared confusion in the market.  So Heller said yes, and changed the title to Catch-22, because “you’re the 22nd publisher I sent the manuscript to”.

….

Saul Bellow had excellent advice for would-be authors.  “Rejections were not altogether a bad thing.  They teach a writer to rely on his own judgment and to say in his heart of hearts, To hell with you”.

Consider this eminent list of authors who overcame rejection:

William Golding’s Lord of the Flies: 20 rejections.

Frank Herbert’s Dune: 23 rejections.

Stephen King’s Carrie: 30 rejections.

The first prize for receiving the most rejections goes to Robert Pirsig.  Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance was rejected 121 times before becoming an international cult classic.

The moral of the story: It’s only a matter of time.

Leave a Reply

Related Posts