My Baseball Card Collection
By Linda S. Gunther
1964. The Bronx. At 11 years old, I had a baseball card collection with over two hundred fifty trading cards I kept in an A&P grocery cardboard box under the bed. My cards were alphabetically organized by baseball team, each team wrapped with a thick rubber band. I was focused on collecting Mickey Mantle cards, the hardest ones to come by in bubble gum packs you bought at the corner candy store. I had a crush on Mickey Mantle. He was a star Yankee, won the MVP award and played at the stadium on Jerome Avenue only five blocks from where I lived.
A chubby buck-toothed kid who lived on my block taught me how to flip baseball cards. I practiced for hours at a time, like a maniac perfecting the flip of the wrist to achieve my goal, which I neared to a 99% success rate. If you flipped the card in just the right way and it landed face-up but your opponent’s card landed face-down, you’d win their card. If you both had the same flip result, you’d do it over and over until one landed face-up and one landed face-down. And so, on the crumbling white stone stoop outside our Bronx apartment building I flipped to win Mickey Mantle baseball cards from pimply boys bursting with puberty and from bullies thinking the stupid girl has no idea what she’s doing.
But I did!
In a matter of a couple of months, I became well-known as the premiere baseball card flipper in my Bronx neighborhood. I honestly didn’t know any other ‘girl’ flippers. I had broken my first glass ceiling at 11 years old.
When Bobby Schwartz, the boy I had a crush on since 3rd grade and was now in my 4th grade class, stopped me outside school and asked if I’d like to flip his Mickey Mantle cards for my Roger Maris cards, I accepted the challenge. Had he heard about my great “card flip” reputation? I hadn’t seen him watching me before. We planned to meet on the stoop outside my building at 3:30. He lived just across the street from me.
I raced home to put on my best white blouse and my new navy blue capri pants. My younger 10-year-old brother knew something was up by the way I gazed in the hallway mirror at my clothes and brushed my hair carefully before picking up the cardboard box full of baseball cards and carrying it outside our building to the stoop.
Bobby was already sitting there on the top step, his blonde hair shining in the June sun. He wore a red and white checkered shirt and blue jeans with cuffs. His light blue eyes opened wide when he noticed the big box in my hands. I thought I saw him peek down my white blouse when I bent over to place the box down on the stone step.
“How many Mantles you got with you?” I asked, and sat down next to him.
“Three,” he said. “But I brought some other good ones. Whitey Fords and Elston Howards.”
I shook my head. “Nope, not interested. I only want to play for Mickey Mantles.” I pretended not to notice the way his reddish-brown freckles sprinkled over his perfect nose and across the smooth skin on his cheeks.
“Let’s do a practice first,” I said. I wanted to see how he flipped his cards. Was he good?
He nodded. “I heard you’re great for a girl but I’ve never seen you flip.” He picked up a card, flicked his wrist and flipped it, then quickly did another. Both cards landed face-down. He didn’t seem to have the flair or the ability. Did he know the rules for flipping? He certainly doesn’t have the right form.
“I was just fooling you,” he laughed. “You’ll see. I’m really good. Let’s see your practice,” he said.
I held the Roger Maris card in my hand in the readied position, at the edges between three fingertips, my middle finger, my index finger, and my thumb, careful to put just enough gentle pressure on the card to achieve my desired outcome. I flicked my wrist up quickly, the heel of my hand ending pointed out to Bobby, my palm open, the card flying. I felt like a magician. The card landed between us, face-up. I could see Bobby’s jaw drop, his mouth hanging open.
“Just a lucky practice,” I said. Oh God, what am I doing? I want him to like me.
Bobby pressed his lips tightly together and gazed down at the Mickey Mantle card in his hand. His neck was long and slender. He had a dot of a birthmark just below his right ear which I sometimes stared at across the aisle in our classroom when he wrote in his notebook. He let out a long sigh. I could feel his breath on my arm.
“Let’s get the real competition going,” he said.
I bit my lip and nodded.
“Okay,” I said. “I’ll say one-two-three, flip! And then we both flip at exactly the same time. Whoever gets heads-up wins the other’s card. And if we tie, then we just do it again until one of us wins.”
“Yeah, I know the rules,” he said. He placed a Mickey Mantle card in his right hand, ready to flip. I really wanted that Mantle card. I did the same, the Roger Maris card in position between my fingertips.
“Hey,” I said, “don’t bend the card too much when you flip it. I don’t want a damaged Mickey Mantle.”
We both grinned.
He’s so cute. I imagined what it would be like to be his girlfriend when we got to high school, go to parties together as a couple, kiss in a dark corner away from friends.
“One-two-three, flip!” I shouted.
A few minutes later, Bobby stood up from the stoop and looked down at me. He placed the three Roger Maris cards he won from me on top of the small stack he had brought over with him.
“Sorry,” he said. “I didn’t mean to beat your ass.”
I shrugged my shoulders. “I must be having a bad flip day. Not like me.”
“Guess so.” He scratched the top of his head. “I heard you were the best.” He turned and started to walk away, headed to where he lived across the narrow street. I stayed seated on the top step and watched his sturdy body move.
When he got to the curb next to my upstairs neighbor’s parked black Buick, Bobby turned to me. “Hey, you like to play cards?”
I raised my eyebrows.
“I-I mean, do you play gin rummy?” he said.
Gin Rummy? I knew about it and that my mother played cards. She loved poker and gin rummy, told me she played a lot in the Navy when she was a WAVE but I had refused to learn because I hated to do what she wanted me to do unless I had to.
“Um, sure,” I said, smiling at Bobby. “I like Gin Rummy.”
“Want to play a card game after school on Monday?” he asked. “I won’t be around this weekend. But I’ll be here Monday.”
“Sure. Um, should we meet here on my stoop?”
“Yeah. I’ll bring a deck of cards,” he said, and started between the parked cars.
His mother, a big woman wearing a paisley dress hollered out from the fire escape outside his second-floor apartment window, just opposite my building.
“Bobby,” she called, looking up and down the steep hill we lived on.
She quickly spotted him, and gestured with her hand, her voice shrill. “Bobby, get up here. We’re leavin’ for Rockaway. You gotta eat something first.”
He gave me a quick wave over his head and raced across the street to his courtyard, and pushed the front door to his building open with his foot.
He hopes I’m still watching him. I mused. Gave up three Roger Maris cards but snagged a date with Bobby Schwartz.
It was my first experience developing a strategy “on the spot.”
Linda S. Gunther is the author of six published suspense novels: Ten Steps From The Hotel Inglaterra, Endangered Witness, Lost In The Wake, Finding Sandy Stonemeyer, Dream Beach and most recently in 2021, Death Is A Great Disguiser. Her short stories have been featured in numerous literary publications. Linda’s passion for travel and continuous learning fuels her fire to create vivid fictional characters and unforgettable story lines.